Being between friend groups as an adult is genuinely painful, and it is not a sign that something is wrong with you. A large Norwegian study found that what predicts loneliness is not how many friends you have, but the gap between the social contact you want and the contact you actually get. In the in-between phase, that gap is at its widest. That is the whole explanation.
What does "between friend groups" actually feel like?
It feels like a specific kind of invisible. You are not friendless in any dramatic sense. There are people you could text. Some would even respond. But the organic, assume-you're-included feeling, the kind where someone just forwards you the invite, is gone. You are aware, at low volume, of its absence almost constantly.
It is not the acute grief of a friendship ending. It is slower. You notice it on Sunday afternoons. You notice it when something happens and your first instinct is to share it, and then you cycle through a short mental list and decide not to bother any of them.
That low-level awareness is not nothing. It is worth taking seriously.
Why does this phase hurt more than simply having fewer friends?
The pain is not about quantity. In a study of 14,725 adults aged 18 to 79, Lappegård and Noack found that across every age group, the strongest predictor of loneliness was not how often someone saw their friends, but how much they wanted to see friends compared to how much they actually did. The aspiration gap. Not the contact deficit.
This is why the in-between phase can feel worse than periods in your life when you objectively had fewer friends. Back then, your expectations had calibrated downward to match. Now, you still carry the expectation of belonging, of easy proximity, of being someone's first call. The expectation hasn't caught up with the reality yet. And that gap, not your social calendar, is what registers as loneliness.
Naming that mechanism matters. Because it means the pain is not evidence of failure. It is evidence of a mismatch that is temporary and structurally predictable.
Why do adults end up between groups in the first place?
Adult social life is not organized the way school was. There, the institution did the assembling: same classroom, same lunch hour, same five-day schedule, same years. Belonging happened at scale and by default.
After that, it doesn't. Every social world you build as an adult requires intentional maintenance, and that maintenance gets harder to sustain across job changes, moves, relationship shifts, and the quiet rewiring that happens when your priorities change and you realize you've grown away from people who still feel the same.
The dissolution of a friend group is rarely dramatic. It is usually incremental: fewer group chats, less overlap, the creeping sense that the original organizing force has gone quiet. By the time you register that you are between groups, the transition has already been happening for a while.
Can a comfort object actually do anything for this kind of loneliness?
A physical object can provide something real, not a cure, but a lowering of the static.
The mechanism is established. When the fundamental need for social connection goes unmet, people reach for external anchors, objects that hold a felt sense of safety. A study investigating transitional object attachment and emotion regulation in adults, measuring heart rate variability as the physiological marker, found that attachment to comfort objects persists into adulthood and influences stress response. Not as self-report. As a body-level signal.
This is not regression. It is the same neurological mechanism that has always governed felt safety, deployed now by an adult who knows exactly what is happening and is using what works. The object holds the space between losing one social world and building the next. It does not replace the connection you are looking for. It makes the in-between more survivable.
If you want to go deeper on the research behind this, our full guide to emotional comfort covers how comfort objects work and what the evidence actually says.
What to actually watch for during the in-between phase
The in-between is a transition, not a permanent state. But some signs suggest it is beginning to harden into something that deserves more attention:
- You have stopped expecting invitations, and the absence no longer registers as a loss.
- You have started declining things preemptively, before anyone has even asked.
- You are spending more time in digital proximity (group chats, passive scrolling) than in actual contact, and that is doing less than you expected.
- The story you are telling yourself has shifted from "I'm between groups" to "I'm just not someone who has close friends."
That last one is the signal worth catching. Because the first is a situation. The second is an identity, and it is usually wrong.
How Bemellou fits into this
The Bemellou plush was built for exactly this: the quiet middle, the in-between phase, the time when you're not ready to book a therapy session or download a new app, but you need something that meets you where you are. Something to hold in the moment. If you want, it opens a door to a wellbeing app with courses, tools, and a community. If you don't, it just stays. Either way is fine.
FAQ
Is it normal to feel lonely even when I technically have friends?
Yes. Loneliness is driven by the gap between the social connection you want and what you are actually getting, not by the raw number of people in your life. You can have a full contact list and still feel genuinely alone if the kind of connection you're looking for isn't there.
How long does the between-groups phase usually last?
There is no fixed timeline. It depends on how many structural changes have happened in your life at once, how much bandwidth you have for building new connections, and whether you are actively in transition or in a more settled period. For most adults, it is a phase, not a permanent state, though it can feel permanent while you are in it.
Is being between friend groups a sign I'm bad at relationships?
No. Adult friendships depend heavily on shared context, proximity, and overlapping schedules, all things that change dramatically across your twenties, thirties, and beyond. The loss of a friend group is almost never about character. It is usually about life reorganizing itself and the social structure not keeping up.
Why does it feel worse in adulthood than it did at university?
Because at university, the institution organized your belonging for you. As an adult, every social world requires active maintenance, and the expectations you carry from that earlier period do not automatically reset when the structure disappears. The aspiration gap, the distance between what you expect and what you have, is often widest in adulthood precisely because the expectations are highest.
What actually helps during the in-between period?
The most useful first move is naming the gap accurately: this is a structural, transitional experience, not a character verdict. After that, small sustained contact matters more than large social events. Physical comfort, routine, and something grounding to hold can lower the background static while you rebuild. Giving yourself permission not to have it figured out yet is not passivity. It is the right response to being genuinely in between.
Last updated: 2026-10-24
Keep reading
Did this sound like you?
Leave a reaction or a few words. Other readers see them, and it helps them feel less alone.
Bemellou isn't a crisis service. If you're struggling right now, please reach a local helpline.